Cold emails work when done right. But most cold emails don’t land in the inbox. They either get ignored, flagged as spam, or bounce before they’re even seen.

If your open rates and reply rates are low or your emails keep getting blocked, you're not alone. The problem usually isn't your offer. It's your cold email checklist or the lack of one.

A cold email checklist keeps your outreach sharp, compliant, and deliverable. It helps you avoid rookie mistakes, protect your domain, and write emails that drive conversations and conversions.

In this guide, you’ll find everything top senders do right:

1. Copywriting that gets replies
2. Technical setup that lands in inboxes

Let’s get into it.

TL;DR: Cold Email Checklist at a Glance

If you want your cold emails to land in inboxes, get opened, and drive replies, start by following these core rules. This quick checklist combines what works across deliverability, content, and sending behavior.

Use it before every campaign.

Cold Email Copy Checklist (What to Write and What to Avoid)

Your cold email copy decides whether someone opens, reads, and responds or deletes. It also plays a major role in email deliverability. The goal is simple: get a reply. To do that, your email must look personal, be easy to read, and feel like it was written just for the recipient.

Let’s break down exactly what works and what doesn’t: 

1. Keep Emails Under 150 Words

Short cold emails perform better. Period.

Across thousands of campaigns, the emails with the highest reply rates almost always stay under 150 words. That’s about 5–7 sentences total. Anything longer risks losing the reader’s attention or triggering a spam filter.

When a decision-maker opens a cold email, they decide in seconds whether to engage or ignore. Long intros, feature dumps, or too much backstory waste that opportunity.

Why short emails win:

• They look personal, not mass-sent
• They load faster, especially on mobile
• They reduce friction to reply
• They’re less likely to hit spam filters due to lower text-to-link/image ratio

What to include in those 150 words:

• A relevant subject line (3–6 words max)
• A short intro (1 sentence) that answers: “Why are you emailing me?”
• Social proof or context (1–2 sentences)
• A benefit-driven CTA (1 sentence) that invites a reply or quick action

Break the message into 2–3 line paragraphs. White space improves readability. No one wants to read a wall of text, especially not from someone they don’t know.

Example (Word count: 87)

Hey Amanda,

I noticed your team’s hiring outbound reps. I’m helping 25+ B2B sales teams automate their cold email setup while improving reply rates by 30% in 4 weeks.

Happy to share what’s working in your space. Open to a quick 10-min call this week?

It’s short, specific, and gives the reader just one thing to do: respond.

What to avoid:

• Long blocks of text with no breaks
• Pitches that feel scripted or generic
• Multiple CTAs (confuses the reader)
• Fluff like “hope this email finds you well”
• Company bios or feature lists
• Over-explaining or trying to sell in the first touch

Keep it focused. Every line should earn the next. If it doesn’t move the conversation forward, cut it.

Pro tip: Write your email. Then cut 30 percent. Trim greetings, combine sentences, and remove anything that doesn’t directly support your message or CTA.

Smartlead’s built-in editor can help you stay under the word limit while optimizing for readability and tone. When in doubt, simpler is better.

2. Include No Links in Your First Cold Email & Use Plain Text, Not HTML

Your first cold email should be plain text with no links. This may seem counterintuitive, but it’s the most effective way to get your email into the inbox and increase the chances of getting a reply.

Why avoid links? 

Email service providers like Gmail and Outlook flag emails with links, especially those with tracking or redirect parameters, as promotional. This increases the likelihood that your email will land in spam or the promotions tab. Links also reduce trust, especially in the first email, and activate stricter spam filters.

The goal of your first cold email isn’t to get someone to click; it’s to get them to respond. Your CTA should focus on starting a conversation, not pushing them to a link. For example, ask a simple question like, “Would you be open to a quick chat next week?” or “Curious to hear if this is something you're exploring.”

Once you’ve made contact and the recipient shows interest, you can include links in your follow-up emails. At that point, their inbox is more likely to trust you, and they’ll be more open to clicking.

In cold outreach, it’s best to avoid HTML-based emails with logos, buttons, or colorful backgrounds. These emails look too much like marketing messages and can hurt your deliverability. Plain-text emails are faster to load, feel more personal, and are less likely to be flagged as spam. They also tend to have better open and reply rates.

Smartlead automatically sends cold emails in plain text unless you choose otherwise. You can also use spintax and A/B testing to create variations of your plain-text emails to further improve deliverability.

3. Write Like a Human

If your email sounds like a sales script or looks like a bulk message, it will get ignored or flagged. Cold emails perform best when they feel like one person reaching out to another. Simple language, natural tone, and clear intent always outperform polished marketing speak.

Aim for a grade 5 reading level. You can check this with tools like Hemingway or even the built-in Email Copywriter tool in Smartlead. Short words, simple sentences, and everyday phrasing help your message land better.

Avoid:

• Buzzwords, filler, or industry jargon
• Complex sentences with multiple clauses
• All-caps subject lines or excessive punctuation
• Words that signal sales intent like “guaranteed,” “buy now,” “limited time”

Write the way you speak. If your email sounds unnatural when read out loud, rewrite it. A good cold email should feel like a message you’d send on LinkedIn or even text. 

4. Don’t Repeat the Same Email in Follow-Ups

Sending the same message twice won’t help you get a reply. In fact, it can hurt your deliverability.

Most inbox providers flag identical content sent in sequence. Repeating the same email in a follow-up tells the system you’re automating at scale. That increases your chances of being filtered out and tells the recipient you didn’t care enough or just lazy.

Instead, rewrite your follow-ups with:

• A different opening line or context
• A new CTA (e.g., ask for feedback instead of a meeting)
• Added social proof or a soft close

For example, if your first email introduced a benefit, the follow-up can ask a direct question or reference a recent event. Keep it short, but make it new.

Changing your message in each follow-up keeps things fresh, feels more personal, and signals to both the recipient and the email provider that you’re not spamming.

5. Focus on Conversation, Not Conversion

Your cold email’s job is to start a conversation, not to close a deal.

Most people delete cold emails because they feel like a pitch. If you ask for a purchase, sign-up, or commitment in the first message, you’re asking too much too soon.

Instead, focus on:

• Asking a relevant question
• Offering insight without pushing
• Inviting a quick chat, not a contract

Good cold emails create openings. Your goal is to get a reply, not a yes. Once the conversation starts, you can qualify, pitch, or convert—just not in the first email.

Here’s a better CTA than “Let me know if you’re interested in buying”:

“Would it make sense to chat for 10 minutes later this week?”

That’s a conversation starter. That’s what works.

Read more about how to write a cold email CTA that converts, here. 

Real SaaS Cold Outreach Example (B2B)

Email 1: Addressing Pain Point 

Subject: Quick Idea to Increase Conversions at [Company]

Hi [First Name],

I noticed that many SaaS teams struggle with [specific challenge]. At [Your Company], we've helped teams improve conversions by 15%+ through a [specific method or solution]. I believe this could be highly beneficial for [Company] as well.

Let me know if you're open to a quick chat about it. I'd love to share how we can help you tackle this challenge.

Email 2: Case Study with Social Proof

Subject: [Relevant Company] Achieved 15%+ Growth with This Approach

Hi [First Name],

I wanted to share a quick success story. We recently worked with [Relevant Company] and helped them increase conversions by 15% in just 6 weeks using the same strategy I mentioned. Here’s a brief overview of the approach we took: [Link to case study or resource].

If you’re interested in learning more or seeing how this could work for [Company], I’d be happy to schedule a quick call.

Email 3: Soft CTA Follow-Up

Subject: Just Checking In – Any Thoughts on My Previous Email?

Hi [First Name],

I wanted to check in to see if you had a chance to review my previous emails. I understand you're likely busy, but I believe the strategy we’ve used with other SaaS companies could make a real difference for [Company].

Would you be open to a 10-minute call to discuss further? Let me know what works best for you.

Email 4: Breakup Email

Subject: Last Chance – Let’s Connect Before I Close Your File

Hi [First Name],

I know priorities shift, and perhaps now isn’t the right time for a conversation. If so, no worries—I’ll close your file and won’t follow up again. But if you’re still interested, I’d love one last chance to chat and explore how we can help [Company] increase conversions.

Please feel free to reach out if now or later works better for you.

 Why this works:

• Addressing Pain Point: Email 1 immediately addresses a relevant pain point for the recipient, offering a tailored solution instead of a generic pitch.
• Social Proof: Email 2 adds credibility with a real-world case study, building trust and showing the solution works.
• Soft CTA Follow-up: Email 3 doesn’t push too hard but invites the recipient to engage on their terms, ensuring the email feels more like a conversation than a sale.
• Breakup Email: Email 4 adds urgency without being too aggressive, allowing the recipient a final chance to engage or walk away.

This structure builds a relationship over time, offering value and proving credibility with every message. Smartlead’s tools like A/B testing and inbox rotation help ensure this sequence is sent at the right time, to the right inbox, with personalized touches.

Cold Email Technical Checklist (Deliverability Must-Dos)

Strong cold email performance starts with the right infrastructure. Before you write the perfect subject line or personalize your pitch, you need to ensure your domain, inboxes, and sending logic are optimized for email deliverability.

If your setup is weak, even the best copy won’t reach your prospect. Use this technical checklist to protect your sender reputation, avoid spam filters, and scale safely.

Never Send from Your Primary Domain

Your company’s main domain (e.g., smartlead.ai) should never be used for cold email outreach. Here’s why:

• Cold outreach is low reply, high risk. Even a few bounces or spam reports can damage your primary domain's reputation.
• ESP penalties apply across the domain. One inbox flagged on smartlead.ai can reduce deliverability across all employees’ inboxes—support, sales, founders, everyone.

The right approach:

• Buy secondary domains that look close to your main domain (e.g., getsmartlead.com, try-smartlead.com, smartleadmail.com).
• Use email hosting (Google Workspace or Zoho) to activate mailboxes on those domains.
• Set up redirects from those domains to your main website in DNS, so anyone who clicks your domain in a cold email still lands on your homepage.

Smartlead advantage: You can connect unlimited domains and inboxes to Smartlead and rotate them automatically to stay well below each domain’s limit while scaling total volume. 

Avoid Alias Addresses

Email aliases (like outreach@smartlead.ai pointing to vaibhav@smartlead.ai) do not carry their own sender reputation. They’re just wrappers over your primary inbox.

Why that’s a problem:

• ESPs (like Gmail) trace sender reputation to the actual mailbox, not the alias.
• If the alias sends hundreds of emails and gets flagged, the real account is penalized.
• You can’t warm up or track performance per alias—inbox behavior is shared.

Use real inboxes. Each sender should have a standalone email address hosted on a complementary domain with its own credentials, SMTP access, and inbox.

Smartlead benefit: Every Smartlead inbox is tracked independently. You can warm them up, rotate them, and monitor performance separately.

Warm Up New Inboxes Slowly

Cold outreach from a fresh domain without warm-up is the fastest way to hit a spam wall.

Why inbox warm-up matters:

• ESPs use algorithms to flag sudden changes in email activity.
• A new inbox jumping from 0 to 50+ emails per day looks suspicious and spammy.
• Warming up an inbox trains Gmail, Outlook, and others to trust your domain over time.

Best practices:

• Start with 5–10 emails/day for the first week.
• Gradually increase by 10–15% per day.
• Prioritize real interactions—emails that get replies, opens, and even forwards.

How Smartlead helps:

• Built-in warm-up engine simulates real conversations between inboxes.
• Auto-replies, flagged-to-primary movements, and open behaviors are baked in.
• No need to integrate third-party warm-up tools.

Pro tip: Keep warm-up running even after going live with campaigns to maintain baseline activity.

Set Up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC

These are not optional. They are the backbone of email authentication.

SPF (Sender Policy Framework)

Defines which servers are allowed to send emails for your domain. Without SPF, receiving servers can't verify your sender identity.

• Prevents sender spoofing
• Increases inbox placement on Gmail, Outlook, etc.

DKIM (DomainKeys Identified Mail)

Adds an encrypted signature to your message, proving it hasn’t been modified in transit.

• Improves trust signals
• Protects from message tampering

DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting & Conformance)

Gives receiving servers instructions on what to do when SPF/DKIM fail. It also sends reports back to you.

• Helps monitor domain abuse
• Enforces stricter sender behavior over time

Setup advice:

• Publish these as DNS TXT records
• Set DMARC policy to “none” during warm-up, then move to “quarantine” or “reject” over time

Additional resource: How to Setup DKIM/SPF/DMARC

Use Custom Tracking Domains

Click/open tracking often uses a redirect URL to collect analytics. By default, most tools use shared domains—like tracking.mailplatform.com.

Problem:
If that domain gets flagged or blocked by Gmail or Outlook due to abuse from another user, your links will stop working or damage your reputation.

Fix:

• Use a custom tracking domain (e.g., track.getsmartlead.com) set up in your DNS
• All redirects go through a branded, safe domain you control

Smartlead integration:

• Supports instant custom tracking domain setup
• Removes dependency on shared infrastructure
• Ensures accurate link and open tracking without hurting deliverability

Don’t Exceed 50 Emails Per Inbox Per Day

Even if Gmail lets you send 2,000 emails per day, don’t do it from a cold outreach account.

Why cap at 50:

• Real humans rarely send more than a few dozen emails/day
• Low volume looks natural to ESPs
• High volume triggers behavior-based spam filters even with good content

Gradual scaling strategy:

• Week 1: 10–15/day
• Week 2: 25–35/day
• Week 3+: up to 50–75 if warm-up and engagement are positive

Smartlead manages this automatically, adjusting send volumes per inbox based on bounce rate, reply rate, and warm-up stage.

Use Spintax and A/B Testing

Spam filters scan for pattern recognition. If 500 people receive the same subject line and body text, you’re guaranteed to get flagged.

Spintax helps break the pattern:

{Hi|Hello|Hey} {first_name},
Just {checking in|following up|reaching out}...

Smartlead spins variations at send-time, so each email is unique—even at scale.

A/B testing goes further by testing different value props, comparing first lines, closing CTAs, tone, etc., and optimising for reply rate without compromising deliverability. 

All this is built directly into Smartlead’s campaign engine—no need to use external split testing tools. 

Randomize Send Times and Delays

Uniform sending is suspicious to email service providers (ESPs). Real people don’t send 47 emails at 9:01 AM sharp, and ESPs are quick to spot such behavior. When you send emails in bursts at identical timestamps, or space them too evenly, it raises a red flag. Similarly, if your email activity is clustered at unnatural hours, it makes your outreach look automated and spammy.

Smartlead solves this by randomizing your sends. It adjusts the exact send time within your chosen window, ensuring that no two emails are sent at the same moment. It also adds delays between each email, ranging from seconds to minutes, and rotates senders across multiple inboxes. This approach mimics natural human behavior and keeps your outreach under the radar of pattern-based spam filters.

Maintain a Do Not Contact (DNC) List

Nothing hurts deliverability more than repeatedly emailing people who have marked you as spam, bounced (either hard or soft), or unsubscribed. Sending to these contacts not only lowers your engagement rates but also increases the likelihood of future emails being flagged.

The best practice is to automatically suppress these contacts across all future campaigns. Keeping a central, shared Do Not Contact (DNC) list across all inboxes and domains is crucial. This ensures that you don’t waste time or resources contacting people who aren’t interested.

Additionally, it’s important to monitor ESP feedback loops where available. These feedback loops provide insights into complaints and help you adjust your outreach strategies.

Smartlead automatically handles this for you. Once someone opts out, they’re blocked across all your inboxes permanently, protecting your reputation and keeping your deliverability high.

Target Business Emails, Not Personal

Sending cold emails to personal domains like @gmail.com or @yahoo.com is a major risk for deliverability.

Why should you avoid personal emails?

• Personal email accounts have tighter spam filters that are more likely to flag unsolicited B2B outreach as spam.
• These accounts don’t expect to receive cold emails and often treat them as unwanted or intrusive.
• Gmail and other personal accounts have stricter limits on how many cold emails you can send, compared to Workspace accounts.

Instead, focus on sending to:

• Verified business domains: These are less likely to get flagged by spam filters.
• Work addresses tied to company websites: Business emails are more likely to be engaged with, and they’re typically easier to find.
• Enriched contacts: Use tools like LinkedIn to match leads with their business email addresses.

Smartlead makes it easy to filter out personal domains and focus only on verified, business-related contacts. By doing so, you improve your chances of staying out of spam folders and reaching your target audience directly.

Scaling Cold Emails With Smartlead

Once your cold email system is working, the next challenge is scaling it without hurting deliverability. That’s where most teams struggle. Traditional platforms and manual methods simply don’t hold up when you try to send thousands of emails per week. Smartlead was built to solve that.

Using Smartlead’s automation and perfect deliverability, users have scaled up their lead generation business by 800%. 

Scaling manually is hard and error-prone:

• You have to buy and set up multiple domains
• Create separate inboxes
• Manage warm-ups
• Rotate inboxes
• Track each one individually
• Stay under sending thresholds manually

Every additional step increases your risk of hitting a limit, damaging your domain, or getting blacklisted.

And that’s before you even think about copy, follow-ups, or replies.

Smartlead’s Deliverability Engine

Smartlead solves cold email at scale from the ground up. It manages everything Gmail doesn’t, with a deliverability-first approach.

Here’s how it works:

1. Inbox Rotation
Smartlead distributes your emails across multiple inboxes automatically. You can send 50 emails per inbox per day. With 20 inboxes, that’s 1,000 cold emails per day, safely and within Gmail’s rules.

No one inbox carries too much risk. Each one is monitored independently for performance, bounce rates, and replies.

2. Automated Warm-Up
New inboxes are warmed up using Smartlead’s engine. It sends real-looking emails, gets replies, avoids spam triggers, and gradually builds reputation.

You don’t need to run warm-up tools or coordinate schedules manually. Just connect the inbox and Smartlead handles the rest.

3. Spintax + A/B Testing Built-In
Spam filters flag repetition. Smartlead uses spintax to vary subject lines, intros, and phrases in every sentence. You can also A/B test entire message variants.

This keeps your copy unique at scale and improves overall response rates while protecting inbox placement.

4. AI-Personalized Emails That Stay Human
Use merge tags and Smartlead’s AI assist to personalize at scale. Emails stay short, clean, and human with no automation footprint. Better personalization = more replies and fewer spam complaints.

5. Unified Inbox Management
Smartlead gives you a single unified inbox view for all senders. You don’t need to log into 20 accounts to track replies. Everything is centralized, searchable, and manageable from one dashboard.

6. Auto-Unsubscribe + Reply Detection
Smartlead automatically stops follow-ups to leads who reply or unsubscribe. This keeps your campaigns compliant and your sender reputation clean.

Set Up Campaigns and Scale It

Scaling cold outreach should never come at the cost of quality or your domain’s reputation. Smartlead is designed to help you build your outreach infrastructure once and scale it confidently without any hassle.

You focus on the key areas like targeting, messaging, and strategy. Smartlead takes care of the rest. It handles warm-up, deliverability, rotation, inbox management, and all necessary technical safeguards to keep your emails on track and out of spam.

With Smartlead, you can scale your outreach across 10, 20, or even 100 inboxes without worrying about blocks, hitting limits, or losing track of conversations.

While you work on crafting better emails, Smartlead ensures they get delivered, with optimized performance at every step.

With impeccable email deliverability, Smartlead users have achieved an outstanding 75% positive reply rates. 

Cold Email Checklist FAQs

How long should cold emails be?

Keep cold emails under 150 words. Short messages feel more personal and get higher reply rates. Use brief paragraphs, avoid filler, and focus on one goal—starting a conversation, not closing a deal.

How many links should a cold email include?

The first cold email should include no links. Links trigger spam filters and make emails feel promotional. If you must include one, do it only in follow-ups, and keep it to a single trusted domain.

How can I avoid the spam folder when sending cold emails?

To avoid spam folders, warm up your inbox, authenticate your domain with SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, send plain-text emails, avoid spammy language, and keep volume under control. Smartlead automates these steps so you stay compliant and land in inboxes.

What is Spintax and how does it help?

Spintax is a way to vary parts of your email using alternative phrases. This helps avoid repetitive content across hundreds of emails. It improves cold email deliverability by making each message look unique. Smartlead supports spintax by default.

Can I use Gmail to send cold emails?

Yes, but with limits. Gmail caps free accounts at 500 emails/day and Workspace at 2,000. To scale outreach, use tools like Smartlead that rotate multiple Gmail inboxes, automate warm-up, and manage deliverability at scale.

Your Checklist to Cold Email Success: At a Glance 

Cold email works—when it’s done right. You need a system that respects inbox rules, earns trust with ESPs, and delivers real value to prospects.

This checklist helps you:

• Structure short, high-performing cold emails
• Avoid spam folders through strong technical setup
• Scale campaigns across inboxes without manual work
• Protect your sender reputation as you grow

Smartlead takes care of everything behind the scenes—from warm-up and authentication to inbox rotation and tracking. You just focus on writing good emails and reaching the right people.

Ready to scale your cold outreach without risking your domain? Try Smartlead today.

‍

‍