When it comes to email marketing, hitting “send” is just the tip of the iceberg. A key player in this process is your domain reputation—the metric that influences how Email Service Providers (ESPs) view your emails.

A solid reputation signals to ESPs that your emails are valuable and relevant, leading to higher email deliverability rates.

In fact, studies reveal that 79% of marketers consider email to be their most effective channel for acquiring customers, but this effectiveness hinges on maintaining a strong domain reputation.

21% of emails never reach the intended inboxes due to poor deliverability stemming from a low domain reputation.

Email Service Providers (ESPs) assess your domain reputation based on a variety of deliverability practices, including engagement rates, bounce rates, and the frequency of spam complaints.

In this blog we'll focus on a crucial element that impacts your email deliverability: email domain reputation and provide actionable strategies to enhance it. We'll answer most searched questions such as:

• What exactly is domain reputation, and why is it important?
• How can you check your domain reputation effectively?
• What tools are available for monitoring your reputation?
• What steps can you take to improve a damaged domain reputation?
• How can you prevent future reputation issues?

 Let’s dive in:

What is Domain Reputation?

Domain reputation is a critical factor that Internet Service Providers (ISPs) use to determine whether your emails can be trusted. In 2024, new sender requirements from Google and Yahoo will further impact your reputation and deliverability.

Think of ISPs as border security for your emails. They meticulously check each message at the gate before allowing it through. If your sending history is solid and you haven’t violated any email best practices, you’re likely to be welcomed with open arms.

However, if you’ve made missteps, such as sending spam or engaging in phishing activities, you might find your emails turned away.

This analogy underscores a vital point: just as border security prioritizes travelers with a clean record, ISPs deliver emails from reputable senders directly to the recipient's inbox.

In contrast, emails associated with poor domain reputations and suspicious content are often relegated to the spam folder.

ISPs are especially vigilant when it comes to domains with histories of phishing or spoofing attacks, quickly discarding any emails from such senders. This means that maintaining a good domain reputation is essential for ensuring your emails reach their intended audience.

Each mail service provider employs its own unique algorithm to assess domain reputation, making it a complex and nuanced aspect of email deliverability. Your reputation score is influenced by the data collected by each mailbox provider regarding the emails sent from your domain.

For instance, if a higher percentage of Yahoo users mark your emails as spam compared to Gmail users, your domain reputation will likely suffer more with Yahoo.

When an incoming mail server receives an email from your domain, it checks your reputation score to determine whether to deliver your message. This score isn’t based solely on your sending domain; it also considers several other factors, including:

• Return-Path Domain: The address where non-delivery receipts and SMTP error messages are sent.
• DKIM Signing Domain: This domain is crucial for authenticating your emails.
• Content Hosting Domain: The domain where images and other content within your emails are hosted.
• Links in Your Email Content: The domains linked in your email can also impact your reputation.

In essence, domain reputation is a score assigned to your domain by email service providers (ESPs) and anti-spam services. This score ranges from 1 to 100, with a simple rule: the higher the score, the better your reputation.

A strong domain reputation is crucial for successful email deliverability, impacting whether your messages land in the inbox or the spam folder.

What Factors Affect Your Email Domain Reputation?

Your email domain reputation is influenced by several critical factors, including spam complaint rates, spam traps, engagement rates, unsubscribe rates, bounce rates, blacklists, and sending history:

1. Spam Complaint Rates

Every time a recipient clicks that ‘Mark as spam’ button, you receive a spam complaint. While a single complaint may not devastate your reputation, it contributes to a larger picture. Ideally, your spam complaint rate should remain below 0.1% to keep your domain in good standing.

2. Spam Traps

Spam traps, often referred to as honeypots, are email addresses designed to identify spammers. There are two main types to be aware of:

• Pristine Spam Traps: These are unused email addresses that have never been associated with a legitimate user. If you send emails to these addresses, it signals to ISPs that your practices are questionable.
• Recycled Spam Traps: These were once valid addresses but are no longer in use. ISPs use these to check if you are regularly cleaning your email list. While landing emails in this category isn’t catastrophic, it can still harm your domain’s spam score.

3. Engagement Rates

Engagement rates are a clear indicator of how interested your audience is in your emails. This metric typically considers open and click rates:

• Open Rates: A high open rate suggests that your subject lines are effective and your audience is engaged.
• Click Rates: This measures how many recipients clicked on links in your email. Low engagement rates can negatively impact your domain reputation, signaling to ISPs that your content may not be relevant.

4. Unsubscribe Rates

Unsubscribe rates also reflect your audience’s engagement. You can calculate this by dividing the number of unsubscribes by the total number of delivered messages and multiplying by 100.

For instance, if you delivered 20,000 emails and 200 recipients unsubscribed, your unsubscribe rate would be 1%. Aim to keep this number around 0.5%.

5. Bounce Rates

High bounce rates can detrimentally affect your email deliverability. There are two types of bounces:

• Hard Bounces: These occur due to permanent delivery errors, such as invalid email addresses.
• Soft Bounces: These are temporary delivery failures, such as a full inbox. Understanding the difference can help you manage your sending practices effectively.

6. Blacklists

Blacklists are databases that flag IP addresses and domains known for sending spam. Common blacklists include Spamhaus and Barracuda. If your domain finds itself on one of these lists, your reputation will likely suffer significantly.

7. Sending History

Your sending history plays a vital role in shaping your reputation. Inconsistent emailing patterns can alert ISPs, increasing the likelihood that your emails will be marked as spam.

8. Inconsistency in Email Sending Volume

Legitimate marketers typically see steady growth in their subscriber base, leading to a consistent increase in email volume. Sudden spikes in email frequency can raise red flags. Finding the right balance in your email cadence is essential for maintaining a good reputation. Check out our guide on optimizing your email frequency for best results.

9. Domain Age

The age of your domain matters. Anti-spam filters consider domain age when assessing reputation.

Warming up your domain—using it for at least three months for cold emailing—can help establish a positive sender reputation. Additionally, be mindful of the quality of your domain name, as it also contributes to your overall reputation.

Domain Reputation Vs. IP Reputation

The composite score of email is primarily determined by two key components: IP reputation and domain reputation. Together, these factors influence how mailbox providers assess your emails. 

Domain Reputation

Domain reputation pertains to the standing of your sending domain, evaluated based on past sending patterns and recipient engagement. Unlike IP reputation, domain reputation is tied to the domain name itself and is much more permanent. This means that maintaining a positive domain reputation requires ongoing diligence.

When considering domain reputation, there are three types of domains involved:

1. From Address: The address displayed to recipients.
2. Return-Path Domain: The address used for bounce messages.
3. DomainKeys Identified Mail (DKIM) Signing Domain: The domain used to verify the authenticity of the email.

Each of these domains plays a role in how ISPs assess your domain reputation. Therefore, maintaining a strong reputation necessitates careful management of all three.

• Focused on the Brand: Domain reputation is linked to your sending domain (your brand’s URL) and reflects the credibility of the emails associated with that domain.
• Relates to Content and Engagement: This reputation is primarily influenced by the quality of your email content and recipient engagement metrics, such as open rates and click-through rates.
• Long-term and Portable: Domain reputation builds over time and isn’t tied to a specific IP address, allowing it to remain intact even if you switch email service providers.

IP Reputation

An Email Service Provider (ESP) utilizes a pool of IP addresses to send emails. While some businesses opt for dedicated IP addresses, most senders share IPs with various other accounts due to the high cost of private ones.

IP reputation reflects the reputation of the specific IP address from which emails are sent. If you’re using a dedicated IP, your reputation relies solely on your sending practices. However, with shared IPs, the behavior of all senders using that address affects your reputation. For instance, if a spam complaint arises from one sender on a shared IP, it could lead to blacklisting for everyone using that IP.

IP reputation is assessed through several factors, including bounce rates, spam complaints, and the volume of Unwanted Bulk Email (UBE). It's important to note that IP reputations can be reset by changing the IP address, giving you a fresh start if needed.

• Focused on the Source: IP reputation pertains to the specific IP address from which your emails are sent. It measures the trustworthiness of emails originating from that address.
• Shared vs. Dedicated Impact: If you're using a shared IP, your reputation can be affected by the actions of other users on that same IP. However, with a dedicated IP, you have full control over its reputation, as it is solely tied to your sending behavior.
• Influenced by Volume and Behavior: The reputation of an IP can be negatively impacted by high sending volumes, especially if they lead to spam complaints or are marked as junk. Conversely, consistently good sending practices can enhance its reputation.

Domain and IP reputation are intertwined. If your IP reputation is strong but your domain reputation is lacking, your overall sender reputation will still be negatively affected—and vice versa.

While ISPs prioritize IP reputation, mailbox providers and Email Service Providers (ESPs) focus more on the sender domain reputation. This distinction highlights the need for a holistic approach to managing both aspects of your email marketing strategy.

What is Considered a Good Domain Reputation?

For cold email campaigns to thrive, maintaining a strong domain reputation is essential. Ideally, you should aim for a domain reputation of 85 or higher. A reputation in this range signals to Internet Service Providers (ISPs) that you are a trustworthy sender, which significantly enhances your chances of landing in recipients’ inboxes.

On the other hand, if your domain reputation hovers around or dips below 70, it’s considered poor. This level of reputation can raise red flags with ISPs, leading to lower deliverability rates and increasing the likelihood that your emails will be sent to the spam folder.

How to Check Your Domain Reputation?

Measuring your domain reputation has specific criteria and data used to generate these scores are kept confidential. This privacy helps prevent spammers from manipulating the system. 

When it comes to assessing your domain reputation, you have two primary options: manual checks or online tools.

How to Manually Check Your Domain Reputation?

One of the most reliable methods is to sign up for a Feedback Loop (FBL). 

An email feedback loop (FBL), sometimes referred to as a complaint feedback loop, is a crucial mechanism that allows Internet Service Providers (ISPs) to inform sending organizations about spam complaints submitted by their recipients.

This valuable feedback helps senders promptly remove those email subscribers from their lists, ensuring they won’t continue to receive unwanted messages or file additional spam complaints.

By addressing spam complaints, senders can keep their complaint rates low. A lower spam complaint rate not only enhances your chances of reaching recipients’ inboxes but also decreases the likelihood of ISPs quarantining or rejecting your messages.

Offered by most mailbox providers and Email Service Providers (ESPs), FBLs track spam complaints and engagement metrics. If you notice a sudden spike in spam complaints, it’s a clear indicator that your email sender reputation is at risk.

How Does an Email Feedback Loop Work?

Each ISP provides its own feedback loop, and it's essential for sending organizations—whether they're using an Email Service Provider (ESP) or managing emails independently—to register for these loops. Typically, an FBL utilizes a button or link that allows recipients to submit complaints about unwanted emails.

While some ISPs send detailed information about each individual complaint, others, like Gmail, offer aggregate data without revealing which recipients filed the complaints.

This means it’s vital for businesses to promptly remove anyone who files a complaint from their mailing lists, ideally through an automated process to minimize human error.

Keep in mind, though, that FBLs are limited to the specific mailbox provider or ESP you register with. For instance, signing up for Gmail’s FBL will only provide insights relevant to Gmail users. Google won’t share data about interactions with other email clients, which means you might miss out on valuable information from other platforms.

Another effective method for gauging your domain reputation is by monitoring your delivery rates. If you observe a decline in emails landing in inboxes, it’s likely that your domain reputation is suffering.

While these manual methods can give you a general sense of your reputation, they may not be sufficient to pinpoint specific issues or implement targeted solutions. For a more comprehensive analysis, consider complementing these methods with specialized tools.

How to Implement the Feedback Loop in Gmail

To leverage the FBL, senders need to include a new header called Feedback-ID. This header consists of parameters (referred to as "Identifiers") that uniquely identify individual campaigns.

Any identifiers that trigger a high spam rate can be monitored in the Postmaster Tools FBL dashboard.

Header Format:

Feedback-ID: a:b:c:SenderId

• Feedback-ID: Name of the header.
• a, b, c: Optional fields for up to three Identifiers (e.g., campaign, customer).
• SenderId: A mandatory unique identifier (5–15 characters) chosen by the sender.

The aggregate data will be generated based on the first four fields of the Feedback-ID, starting from the right. If the SenderId is empty, no data will be generated; if another field is empty, data will still be produced for the remaining fields.

To prevent spoofing of the Feedback-ID, ensure that the emails sent to Gmail are DKIM signed by a domain you own or control after adding this header. Additionally, this domain should be verified in the Gmail Postmaster Tools to access the FBL data.

• Ensure you have only one verified Feedback-ID header in your traffic.
• Publish the sending IPs in your SPF records.
• Use valid hostnames for sending IPs with PTR records.
• For FBL reports, make sure the identifiers across fields are not repeated to avoid aggregation of unrelated data.

What Tools Can I Use to Check My Domain Reputation?

There are both free and paid tools available that allow you to check your domain reputation and other crucial deliverability metrics.

One effective tool to gauge your domain reputation is Google Postmaster Tools. This platform compiles data from various ESPs to provide you with an average score, giving you insight into your standing across different services.

1. Google Postmaster Tools

Google Postmaster Tools is a free resource that offers a wealth of information on your domain and IP reputation. This tool provides key metrics such as your email sender score, spam rate, and encrypted traffic levels.

Specifically tailored for Gmail users, it allows you to conduct an in-depth assessment of your reputation within this major email service.

For those new to the platform, navigating Google Postmaster Tools can feel a bit overwhelming. To help you get started, we’ve put together a comprehensive guide on how to effectively use this valuable tool.

2. Talos Intelligence

Talos Intelligence, powered by Cisco, provides an in-depth look at your IP and domain reputation. This comprehensive tool allows you to enter your IP, domain, or network owner to access real-time threat data.

With its extensive database, Talos offers valuable insights into your sender score and overall performance, helping you identify areas for improvement.

3. MxToolBox

MxToolBox is another excellent choice for checking your domain reputation. Simply enter your domain or IP address, and the tool will run a diagnostic check to uncover any blacklist or deliverability issues that might be impacting your reputation. It’s straightforward and efficient, making it a go-to resource for many marketers.

4. Barracuda Reputation Lookup

Barracuda Central offers a reputation lookup tool that checks your IP address against its extensive database of known spammers and reputable senders.

By entering your IP or domain, you can quickly gauge your standing in the email ecosystem. This tool is particularly useful for identifying potential issues that could affect your deliverability.

5. Sender Score by Validity

Sender Score by Validity is an excellent tool for checking your IP, domain, or sender reputation in real time. It scans your domain to identify the owner, locate DNS records, and search for SSL certificates to verify ownership.

Additionally, it ranks sending IPs based on their sending volume and overall sender score.

Sender Score uses a grading scale from 0 to 100, with scores between 85 and 100 indicating a good reputation.

However, aiming for the highest score possible is always recommended, as a stellar reputation significantly boosts your email deliverability.

We have a detailed article on email reputation check tools that covers all the nuances you need to know. Discover the top 11 trending tools in the industry for checking email reputation, complete with in-depth insights and practical tips to help you enhance your email deliverability.

How to Increase Domain Reputation?

Improving your domain reputation can be challenging, but with the right strategies, it's absolutely achievable.

By adopting best practices in email management and establishing a solid email infrastructure, you can gradually enhance your email delivery rates. Here’s how you can get started:

1. Implement Authentication Protocols

Start by setting up authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. These records are crucial for building trust with Internet Service Providers (ISPs). If you need guidance, check out our email authentication guide or explore our YouTube channel for helpful tutorials.

Additionally, don’t overlook the importance of PTR (Reverse DNS) records. While not part of the authentication trio, they play a vital role in verifying your sender identity. Together, these protocols lay the foundation for a strong domain reputation.

2. Warm Up Your Domain

ISPs tend to be cautious with new domains and IPs since they lack a reputation history. To combat this, gradually increase your email volume. Start by sending smaller batches and slowly ramp up as your domain establishes trust.

3. Utilize Subdomains

Consider using subdomains to segment your audience and email campaigns. For example, your main domain (e.g., @mailtrap.io) can support subdomains like @info.mailtrap.io or @support.mailtrap.io. This strategy allows you to separate transactional emails from marketing ones, minimizing the impact of any spam complaints on your main domain’s reputation.

4. Regularly Clean Your Mailing List

Building your mailing list organically is essential, but it’s equally important to maintain its cleanliness. Implementing a double opt-in process helps ensure that subscribers genuinely want to receive your emails, reducing the risk of spam complaints.

Monitor engagement metrics closely. If someone hasn’t opened your emails in months, it might be time to remove them from your list. This proactive approach not only keeps your list healthy but also helps avoid hitting spam traps.

Additional Tips for Enhancing Domain Reputation:

• Use Double Opt-In: Confirm email addresses to validate them and ensure genuine interest.
• Avoid Spam Triggers: Steer clear of spammy words in your subject lines and email copy to enhance inbox placement.
• Remove  Inactive Subscribers: Regularly remove disengaged users to maintain list hygiene.
• Maintain Consistent Cadence: Find the right timing and frequency for your emails to support your domain's reputation.
  

How to Fix a Poor Domain Reputation

If your domain reputation is suffering, don’t worry—here's a comprehensive plan to help you get back on track.

1. Employ Good List Hygiene

Regularly clean your email lists by removing:

• Hard Bounces: Addresses that consistently fail to deliver.
• Inactive Users: Subscribers who haven’t engaged with your emails in months.

2. Improve Email Engagement

Focus on enhancing the quality and relevance of your emails. Here’s how:

• Segment Your Audience: Tailor content to different segments of your list to ensure it resonates with recipients.
• Experiment with Content: Test different types of content and subject lines to discover what drives higher engagement.

By providing value, you’ll improve open and click-through rates, positively impacting your sender reputation.

3. Avoid Spam Traps and Triggers

Be vigilant about spam traps, which can indicate poor list management. Common traps include:

• Misspelled Domains: Such as @yaho instead of @yahoo.
• Recycled Addresses: Email addresses that were once active but are now monitored by ISPs.

Regularly updating and validating your email list can help prevent these issues.Steer clear of language commonly associated with spam, such as “urgent” or “free.” Monitor your content to ensure it aligns with best practices, minimizing the likelihood of your emails being marked as spam.

4. Authenticate Your Sending Domain

Implement email authentication protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC. This ensures that recipient servers can verify your emails are legitimate and haven’t been tampered with during transit.

5. Monitor Your Email Deliverability

Keep an eye on your email delivery rates. If you notice a decline, investigate potential issues immediately. Tools like Smartlead’s dashboard provide insights into deliverability and engagement metrics, allowing you to address problems before they escalate.

6. Warm Up Your IP Address

If you’re using a new IP address, gradually increase your email sending volume over a few weeks. This warming-up process helps establish a positive reputation with ISPs.

Establishing a strong sender reputation is essential for successful email marketing. AI-powered email account warm-ups can help you achieve this by gradually building your sender reputation and ensuring your emails land in your recipients' inboxes, not their spam folders.

Smartlead’s advanced warm-up engine emulates human-like sending behavior, enhancing your reputation over time. This means your emails are more likely to reach the primary inbox. Additionally, Smartlead actively moves emails from spam to the primary inbox, marks them as important, and prioritizes replies, further boosting your visibility.

To enable the warm-up process, follow these simple steps:‍

1. Access Email Accounts: Navigate to the Email Accounts section on the left sidebar.

2. Select Your Email Account: Click on the account you wish to warm up.

3. Choose Your Configuration: Scroll down to adjust your settings.

4. Enable Warm-Up: Click “Enable Warmup” and hit Save. Smartlead will automatically start the warm-up process in the background, ensuring your emails avoid spam.‍

5. Review Statistics: Check your warm-up email statistics daily to monitor progress (allow a few minutes for data to update).

For active campaigns, keep this between 10-20 emails, and increase the volume once the campaign concludes.

• Daily Ramp-Up: If you have a new domain, enable this feature. It gradually increases the number of emails sent daily, preventing ISPs from flagging your account for unusual activity. If your domain is already warmed up or you’re transitioning from another warm-up engine, you can skip this option.
• Randomize Warm-Up Numbers: This feature uses algorithms to mimic human sending patterns within your specified thresholds, improving deliverability and avoiding detection by automated systems.
• Reply Rate: Set the percentage of emails your account will reply to. A healthy reply rate of 20-30% significantly enhances deliverability and reputation. Rates above 30% are not advisable unless you’re experienced in managing this aspect.

7. Quality Control Your Email Lists

Regularly maintain clean and engaged email lists. Remove inactive subscribers to avoid sending emails to those who are no longer interested, which can negatively impact your domain reputation.

Smartlead’s Email Verification feature is your go-to solution for ensuring a clean lead list. Instantly identify invalid and unknown emails to protect your campaigns, improve deliverability, and scale your outreach efforts effectively.

Starting at just $15 USD for 6,000 credits, our email verification service allows you to purchase additional credits as needed, tailored to your requirements.

8. Send High-Quality, Relevant Emails

Finally, prioritize sending valuable, engaging content that aligns with your audience’s interests. Positive interactions with your emails will help you rebuild and maintain a solid sender reputation.

Enhance your email campaigns with dynamic and personalized content by leveraging Spintax. Here’s why and how to implement it effectively.

Spintax helps improve your email deliverability and minimizes the risk of landing in spam folders. By sending "different" versions of the same call-to-action (CTA) or text, email service providers (ESPs) perceive your outreach as personalized rather than mass emails.

This approach tricks ESPs into thinking you’re engaging in genuine conversations, which can significantly boost your email performance.

Additionally, Spintax allows you to identify which copywriting variations resonate best with your audience, all while requiring minimal extra effort.

Step-by-Step Guide to Using Spintax

Step 1: Open Your Email Editor
You can start by editing an existing campaign or creating a new one.

Step 2: Insert Your Spintax Text
In the text editor, format your Spintax text as follows:

• Example 1: {Let's jump on a call | Are you free tomorrow? | Keen for a demo?}
• Example 2: {Hi|Hello|Hey} Pierre

Make sure there are no extra spaces in your Spintax to ensure proper functionality.

Note: Always cross-check your Spintax during the final review to confirm the generated content appears as intended.

By following these steps diligently, you can restore your domain reputation and enhance the success of your email marketing efforts. Consistency is key—keep refining your practices, and you'll see improvement over time!

What Measures Can I Implement to Avoid Domain Reputation Damage?

To safeguard your domain reputation, it's essential to implement proactive measures that foster good emailing practices. Start by maintaining a clean email list, regularly removing inactive or unengaged subscribers to prevent high bounce rates and spam complaints. 

Employ double opt-in methods to ensure that only verified users join your list, enhancing overall deliverability. Additionally, steer clear of spam trigger words in your content, as these can lead to emails being flagged. 

Monitor your sending patterns, gradually increasing email volumes to avoid raising red flags with email service providers. Also, regularly authenticate your sending domain with protocols like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC to bolster your credibility and security.

How Can Smartlead Improve Your Domain Reputation?

Smartlead provides a comprehensive suite of tools designed to enhance your domain reputation effectively. With features like the Blacklist Checker, you can quickly identify if your IP or domain is blacklisted by major email providers.

 The Spam Rate Calculator estimates the likelihood of your emails being flagged as spam, while the Bounce Rate Calculator helps optimize your deliverability by analyzing potential bounce rates. 

Additionally, Smartlead emphasizes best practices such as using double opt-in to ensure only verified users are on your list, warming up your IP address gradually, and implementing robust email authentication protocols. 

Smartlead also includes built-in email verification and spam checkers, ensuring that your email lists are clean and your content is free from common spam triggers.

Together, these tools and strategies empower marketers to rebuild trust and improve email deliverability.

In conjunction with these features, Smartlead recently launched SmartDelivery, an advanced Email Deliverability Suite that takes your email outreach to the next level.

SmartDelivery focuses on optimizing inbox placement with algorithms that ensure your emails consistently land in the inbox, enhancing engagement and campaign performance. 

With comprehensive testing options, both manual and automated, you can gain reliable insights into your email strategies. Real-time monitoring keeps you agile, allowing for adjustments on the fly.

Additionally, with sending throttling capabilities, you can manage your email sending speed to avoid spam triggers. 

SmartDelivery is your all-in-one solution for maximizing deliverability and turning your email campaigns into revenue-generating powerhouses. 

Wrapping Up!

‍
Prioritizing email deliverability and maintaining a robust domain reputation are crucial steps for elevating your marketing efforts.

Smartlead is dedicated to equipping you with the powerful tools and insights necessary to fine-tune your email strategy.

Its  suite of features helps you monitor your sender reputation, clean your email lists, and authenticate your sending domains—all vital components for ensuring optimal deliverability. 

With Smartlead, you can confidently sail through  the complexities of email marketing and turn potential pitfalls into opportunities for success.

Start using Smartlead today to take charge of your email deliverability and elevate your domain reputation